My Cart (0)
  • All Items
  • Seasonal Pies
  • Gift Tins
  • Bake Box
  • Desserts
  •   Log In/Create Account

Featured Text

A great place to share about a sale!

Free Shipping on all Classic Tins!

  • My Cart 0
  • All Items
  • Seasonal Pies
  • Gift Tins
  • Bake Box
  • Desserts
  • My Cart 0
  • My Cart 0

INTRODUCING BAKE BOXES!

Cookie Bake Box

No reviews
Regular
$25.00
Sale
$25.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Assorted Bake Box

No reviews
Regular
$25.00
Sale
$25.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Brownie Bake Box

No reviews
Regular
$25.00
Sale
$25.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 
SOLD OUT

Give Back Bake Box

No reviews
Regular
$25.00
Sale
$25.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

SHOP THE CLASSICS

Bar Cookie Tin

3 reviews
Regular
$48.95
Sale
$48.95
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Small Classic Cookie Tin

2 reviews
Regular
$45.00
Sale
$45.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Large Classic Cookie Tin

1 review
Regular
$75.00
Sale
$75.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Lemon Bars

3 reviews
Regular
$25.00
Sale
$25.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

HANDMADE PIES

NOW SHIPPING NATIONWIDE

ORDER NOW

BEST SELLERS

Pecan Pie

3 reviews
Regular
$45.00
Sale
$45.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Bar Cookie Tin

3 reviews
Regular
$48.95
Sale
$48.95
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Key Lime Pie

2 reviews
Regular
$45.00
Sale
$45.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Small Classic Cookie Tin

2 reviews
Regular
$45.00
Sale
$45.00
Regular
Unit Price
/per 

Let customers speak for us

from 28 reviews

This tin was amazing! My friends couldn't get enough of them and they were gone in minutes!

Cassidy Shull
Small Classic Cookie Tin
03/21/2022
Best Cherry Pie you will ever experience!

Big shout out to Chef Lindsey! First, the pie was shipped to us and looked like we bought it at our local grocery store. It was packed to perfection. I'm not sure how Chef Lindsey does it, between the pie crust and cherries, you can't find a better cherry pie. I think my husband and I died and went to heaven. Oh, and don't forget a scoop or two of your favorite Vanilla ice cream once you pull it out of the oven. Simply the BEST cherry pie ever!!!

Lisa Vollmayer
Tart Cherry Pie
03/15/2022
Excellent gift!

Beautifully presented & beautifully baked! The tin was perfect and all the cookies were delicious and fresh!

Kathryn Farr
Small Classic Cookie Tin
02/22/2022
Loved Sharing the Love

This Valentine's cookie tin was so delicious! Each slice is the perfect size for indulgent experience without being too much. Everyone I gifted these to gave raved reviews! These tins were baked with love through and through!

Janey B
Valentine's Day Bar Tin
02/15/2022
Outstanding cookies!

The cookies in the large Classic Cookie Tin I ordered recently from Pastry Creations were fresh and delicious. I will definitely order more.

JOANN ROTTER
Large Classic Cookie Tin
01/20/2022
Delicious!

We collaborated with Pastry Creations to send our clients a sweet treat for the holidays. It could not have gone smoother! From the attention to detail to the final product being delivered to our clients, everything turned out wondeful. I highly recommend!

Andrew Ervin
Large Christmas Cookie Tin
01/04/2022

It was a gift

e golden
Small Christmas Cookie Tin
12/30/2021
Amazing

I bought these for a friend and she said they were increíble! Thank you!

Jess
Lemon Bars
12/16/2021
Apple Crisp

5 Star
Another Outstanding Creation by Chef Lindsey!
The crust a perfect texture and flavorful.
Inside - generous portion of apples - superb combination of ingredients that brought out a great flavor and richness!!!

Bill Moretti
Apple Crisp
12/07/2021
AAAAAAAAMAZING!

Received a week before Thanksgiving. Put in freezer until the day before. Warmed in oven the day of and smiled with delight over how much my family LOVED this apple pie! There were 3 apple pies total, and while I wasn’t competing for some pie prize, mine from Pastry Creations was hands down the winner 🤣! The apples were crisp perfection and the crust was flaky decadence!

Angela Brooks
Classic Apple Pie
12/07/2021
Incredible!

This pecan pie is AMAZING! It has a wonderful smooth filling, and is not overly sweet. The butter pie crust is delightful, as are the toasted pecans. You will not be disappointed! Thank you Chef Lindsey.

Marilyn M
Pecan Pie
12/03/2021
Best Ever Pumpkin Pie!

A wonderful blend of spices. The butter pie crust is delicious. A family favorite year round. A must try!

Marilyn M
Pumpkin Pie
12/03/2021
Amazing pies

The fam says it’s the best pecan pie they’ve ever eaten! Will definitely order in the future!

Jerry Chang
Pecan Pie
12/02/2021
Best Cherry Pie!

The crust, the cherries, and everything in between… DELICIOUS! Had it shipped to the Midwest and still in great condition when it got here. Easy instructions for warming the pie, creating a warm flaky crust to enjoy. Fan favorite at the thanksgiving party! 😋

Mary Kate Szymaniak
Tart Cherry Pie
12/01/2021
Must Have More!

The Apple Crisp dessert was simply amazing and left me wanting more! I really enjoyed the "crisp" but also enjoyed the refreshing apples. Well done and my compliments to Chef Lindsey!!!

Matt
Apple Crisp
11/21/2021
  • All Items
  • Fall Favorites
  • Pies
  • Cookies & Cookie Tins
  • Seasonal Desserts
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • About
  • Shipping Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy

Be notified about promotions and new items. No spam, unsubscribe anytime!

© 2022 Pastry Creations

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Facebook Pay Google Pay Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Venmo Visa
TOP

Join our mailing list

Be notified about promotions and new items. No spam, unsubscribe anytime!

*By completing this form you're signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time.